Black n' Red Notebook Review


 

Black n' Red Notebook Review
The Black n' Red notebook; Picture taken from Mead's website

Specifications:

Manufacturer: Hamelin Brands distributed by Mead in the U.S.
MSRP: $10
Actual Price: $8-$15
Price I paid: $7.95 from Office Depot (It's now $10.99)
Availability: You can find these notebooks at almost all of the major office supply stores, including Staples and Office Depot, and even at some drugstores like Rite-Aid.
Sizes: A4, A5, and A6
Format: Lined
Sheets/Pages: 70 sheets/140 pages
Weight: 90gsm/ 24#
Online RetailersThis page on their website shows many of the companies that stock their products. Others include AmazonOffice max, and Mead's website.

Thoughts

Introduction:

I use these notebooks almost everyday for my classes and have gone through several, so I feel qualified to write an extensive, unbiased review about them.


When I first bought one of these notebooks, I was looking at Office Depot for paper. I found these and fell in love with the way they looked, so I bought two of them. To my surprise, the paper was just as smooth as Clairefontaine, if not smoother. At only two dollars more than the Clairefontaine notebooks (I'll review one of those eventually), you get stiffer, thicker covers which are better to use as a writing surface and twenty more sheets of paper. 

The Writing Experience:

Writing on this paper for the first time is an astounding experience. Even the scratchiest nibs (including cheap Cross and Chinese pens) instantly become as smooth as much nicer gold ones.  In addition to this, wonderful nibs become even greater and display shading fantastically. It's easily comparable to Rhodia, Clairefontaine, Field Notes, and other well-respected brands. 

Black n' Red paper does have one very unique advantage (or problem for some people) over its competition: it somehow makes all line widths appear finer than on any other paper. Writing with Levenger Cobalt Blue on any other paper, I would say that my Lamy Safari with a fine nib is a medium or even a broad. On this paper, it's drastically finer with no increase in feedback. Lovers of German broad nibs will most likely loathe this, but I love it as it allows me to use my German mediums and broads more often for note taking. In this thread on FPN, several people discuss the change in line width.
Black n' Red Notebook Review
A blank page

Drying Times:

As with all high-quality paper, drying times skyrocket by 50% to 100% (the difference between 15 seconds and 30 seconds) while writing on it. The reason for this is that low-quality paper is usually more absorbent, meaning that it draws in the ink faster and drying times decrease, whereas high-quality paper is usually far less absorbent and repels ink, increasing drying times. As this is the case with almost all high-quality paper, I do not find fault with this at all.

What I do dislike about his paper is that approximately every ten pages (about 14 pages in this notebook), you'll encounter a page which is so resistant to ink that drying times become laughable. One page in my notebook refused to dry for several weeks, ruining the notes I had taken on it. Knowing this, I now check drying times with the first few sentences, and if they're higher than usual I'll move on to the next page. After going through several of these notebooks, this procedure has saved at least 50 pages from smearing and becoming unreadable.

The Binding and Covers:

The paper in a notebook could be the greatest in the world, but it wouldn't be suitable for my use if the covers weren't thick enough or the binding came apart easily. Thankfully, this notebook has fantastic covers. Both are thick and stiff- great to use as impromptu writing surfaces. The binding is also strong, and pages don't fall out unless you apply a great amount of force.

A slight complaint I have about the covers is that the inside pocket is not wide enough to hold most paper I use as a student, meaning that I have to carry more folders with me. This won't affect you if you'll be using them at home, but it's bothersome to open a separate folder to store a handout quickly.

Availability:

I can confidently say that these notebooks are the most widely available notebooks of their quality. Similar notebooks like the Rhodia Meeting Book and Clairefontaine notebook are hard to find aside from stationery stores and online retailers. You can walk into your nearest office supply store, and you'll have a high chance of finding them. They're even available at Rite-Aid of all places. 

One slight drawback of the wide availability is that I find self buying these notebooks often. When you can just walk into a store with hundreds of locations and buy a product, there's very little holding you back from doing so. 

Writing Sample:

Pen 1: Lamy Safari F filled with Levenger Cobalt Blue
Pen 2: Sailor 1911 Mid-Size EF filled with Levenger Cobalt Blue
Pen 3: Montblanc Meisterstuck 146 F filled with Pelikan Edelstein Topaz
Pen 4: Visconti Rembrandt F filled with Levenger Blue Bahama
Pen 5: Pelikan M200 F filled with Noodler's Black
Pen 6: Montblanc Carrera EF filled with Pelikan Brilliant Black
Pen 7: Cross Classic Century M filled with Cross Black
Pen 8: Cross Bailey M filled with Cross Blue-Black
Pen 9: Parker 45 F filled with Waterman Serenity Blue
Pen 10: Sheaffer Stylist F/EF (The nib is reversible) filled with Sheaffer Skrip Black
Pen 11: Speedball C-4 Dip Nib with Noodler's Habañero
Pen 12: Speedball C-4 Dip Nib with Noodler's Midnight Blue
Pen 13: Pilot Varsity Blue M
Pen 14: Pilot Varsity Purple M
Pen 15: Kuretake Brush Pen filled with Kuretake Black


Black 'n' Red Notebook Review
Writing Sample-Front

The scans are color-accurate on my screen, but you may have to adjust your monitor. This paper is very good with shading and practically eliminates feathering, show through, and bleed through.  If you compare writing on this paper to writing on copier paper or even Levenger and other high-quality paper, you'll notice what I mentioned earlier about nibs seeming finer.

For comparison, here are two writing samples on different papers which clearly show the effect Black n' Red paper has on line width.

Writing on copier paper with the same Lamy Safari and the same ink 

Writing on Levenger paper with the same Lamy Safari and the same ink 


Black 'n' Red Notebook Review
Writing Sample-Back



There is very minimal bleed through except for the words written with Levenger Cobalt Blue. I have a separate review for that ink, and it performs that way on all paper. Show through is non-existent in real life but becomes much more apparent in scans.




The Personal Information Page

The General Information Page with the Narrow Pocket

Pros:

  • Very smooth
  • Available as a lined, spiral-bound notebook (Rhodia does make one, but few retailers carry them. Clairefontaine also produces notebooks, but they aren't even close to the Black n' Red ones in quality and value)
  • Inexpensive for what it is
  • Able to use both sides of pages
  • Thick, hard covers which can be used as writing surfaces
  • Available almost anywhere


Cons:


    • Occasionally, I would encounter a page which would refuse to dry. Even after several days, the writing would still be wet. Thankfully, this occurs rarely, and when it does you can quickly switch to the next page.
    • Only available in the lined, project book, and meeting book formats (I actually don't mind this as I only use lined notebooks, but I know that many others will.)
    • Too few pages for extended note taking (I went through several just for one class)
    • The pocket on the general information page isn't wide enough to hold most papers.

    Gallery:

    Black n' Red Notebook Review
    Black n' Red Notebook Review
    Black n' Red Notebook ReviewBlack n' Red Notebook Review


    SHARE ON:

    1 comments:

    1. Great post. It is important to be guided when writing any kind of term papers.

      ReplyDelete